Beowulf and odysseus a comparison

Like the journey of Beowulf, that of Odysseus in this case is uneventful, but far more wondrous. There seems to be evidence that one of the patterns found in the story of Odysseus also underlies a section of the first half of Beowulf.

Beowulf vs. Odysseus ( Block Diagram)

He also acted on a great deal of faith by not battling Grendel with any type of weapon. As for a possible vestige of the loss of both ship and companions, it should be noted that the ship of the Phaeacians was turned to stone on its return, but of its crew nothing was said.

It occurs at a different point in the story. Both heroes are uniquely grand men in their times, able to do and survive things that no other could. And for myself, I would rather live through untold hardships to get home in the end and see that happy day, than come back and die at my own hearth, as Agamemnon died by the treachery of Aegisthus and his wife.

At the same time, these differences are also very much owing to the cultures which chose to elevate such men as their heroes. These companions are, however, not a necessary element in the section of story that we are considering.

They share at least one traditional story pattern. However their strength differed in that Odysseus had only human strength, while it seemed that Beowulf had supernatural He also demonstrated courage when he listened to the Sirens.

The importance of money and retribution in the cultures may, perhaps, be seen by the role which "gifts" played in heroism.

Beowulf and Odysseus: a Comparison

For when they are rescued they are tearful with joy and gratitude for his returning to save them. And then [we] sat waiting till the Cyclops should come in.

The themes of insult and reply are the most distinctive in our sequence in both poems, because they mar the joy and peace of the banquet and entertainment. In the Old English poem we have the following sequence: In the Odyssey the pattern is as follows A Odysseus builds a raft on the island of Ogygia, where he is being detained by Calypso, B crosses a body of water, on which he loses his ship but is provided a substitute for one by Ino, C encounters Nausicaa and her maidens on the shore, and D is directed to the palace of Alcinous, E where he is graciously received and entertained, except that F during the games he is, without provocation, insulted by Euryalus, but G after he has proven himself, H the entertainment continues, including his identification and story of his adventures, and is ended I by all going to bed.

As a matter of fact, the "shipwreck" the loss of the raft in the Odyssey pattern under consideration could be thought of as a duplication of the great shipwreck in which the remnant of his companions was finally lost, just before his arrival at Ogygia.

Odysseus cares about his men and goes out of his way to save them on more than one occasion. Beowulf and Odysseus Hero Comparison By: But Beowulf, confident in himself and himself alone, went anyway with no comrades to stand beside him save for Wiglaf.

Please can you compare Odysseus in The Odyssey to Beowulf in Beowulf as epic heroes in an essay?

There is a certain degree of boastfulness and self-certainty in both that can be seen either as endearing or rather conceited. Opportunism in terms of gold is not the only issue of lust which divides the two protagonists. Identification of the hero is present at this point in the northern song, but not in Homer.

Vilification also takes several forms. When he acts heroically, he generally does so in hope of gaining the monetary pleasure of kings.

Beowulf and Odysseus: a Comparison

Odysseus spends much of his journey haphazardly struggling against gods and demigods and the elements. We will write a custom essay sample on Beowulf and Odysseus: In the end Beowulf had to stand alone for his glory, as he had all along.

Athena, in disguise as Mentor, rounds on him with Telemachus, … What a thing to say! The entire Odyssey can be seen as a flight from one woman to another, and Odysseus is frequently delayed on his trip by deciding to stay in the arms of a woman for a period of time. Actually, most of Odysseus' landfalls involve female figures; the land of the Cyclops is one of the few exceptions.

In the Odyssey, although the companions have all been lost at the moment we are studying, they are, of course, a significant element in Odysseus's complete story. This is an obvious cultural difference.What is interesting about the comparison between these two characters is the way that Odysseus is shown by Homer to be a character who definitely has to learn a number of important life lessons.

Beowulf and Odysseus are alike in that they are epic heroes. Their differences in characteristics and personality affect the way their men respond to them. Beowulf is out for glory and only for himself and thus his men abandon him in his hour of need.

Beowulf and Odysseus Hero Comparison. When one thinks of a hero, often the picture of a brute, young man with large muscles comes to mind. It is a rare occasion when one is asked to describe a hero that the first word out of their mouth is “smart”/5(1).

Beowulf and Odysseus are alike in that they are epic heroes. Their differences in characteristics and personality affect the way their men respond to them. Beowulf is out for glory and only for himself and thus his men abandon him in his hour of need.

Comparing the values between Beowulf and The Odyssey Loyalty Fate Conclusion Both characters displayed traits of an epic hero.

Beowulf and Odysseus Hero Comparison

Both displayed courage and. A Block Diagram showing Beowulf vs.

Beowulf vs. Odysseus ( Block Diagram)

Odysseus. You can edit this Block Diagram using Creately diagramming tool and include in your report/presentation/website.

Beowulf and odysseus a comparison
Rated 4/5 based on 10 review